Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Come in, pull up a chair, let's discuss all things Ryzom-related.
Locked
User avatar
tleilaxu
Posts: 163
Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2004 8:56 pm

Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by tleilaxu »

After Stigian and I spent some time exploring Chapter 1 on the Advanced Test Server here are our impressions of the forthcoming changes:

1. Kudos to Nevrax on the design of the magic gloves. We took some screens of the Medium & High Quality Magic Amps posted to our guild forums at http://www.minyatur.net. We're very excited to have them on the real servers but are not looking forward to gathering the mats required to craft them as will be pointed out later in this post.

Stigian with the Medium Q amps:



Me with the High Q amps:




2. Being able to buy player made goods is a big boon. One suggestion that I do have is to segregate the regions as has been previously mentioned. It makes merchanting an option for those who like to buy low and sell high. Also, as of right now there is no way to select multiple items to sell at once.
When grinding craft, I make more than several hundred items at once and would like to easily be able to choose the direct sale to NPC method. The system currently implemented in the vendors on ATS requires several clicks to do this and the process must be repeated for each item. Perhaps if the option to sell direct to the NPC should be set as default instead of vice versa. This would fix this problem.

3. The MP3 player is a very nice feature, but it vanished my hardware option enabled mouse (you can enable hardware mouse control in the interface options under game options). So hopefully they fix it soon otherwise I will be using winamp as per usual.

4. The encyclopedia window is in but empty. Content soon I hope!

5. VERY happy with the new Poison spell effect. It looks much cooler than the original animation and comes with a wicked snake hissing & rattling effect. Lightning has been redone as well and looks absolutely fantastic too.
Shockwave & Fire have not been modified.

6. NOT happy with the lack of ostentatiousness of the Living Pike versus the Burning Sword of the Fyros, the Waving Sword of the Trykers or the Electric Lance of the Zorai. Comeon Nevrax make Living look like something better than tiny drops of acid :) Snake animations like the Poison spell perhaps?

7. Loading window music is very dramatic and well done. Same goes for the in game spell effects & sounds.

8. Blind and other afflictions have been fixed and do what they were supposed to do as intended.

9. Land specific mats can only be used in race specific crafted items, one exception being Prime Roots mats which can be used for any race's craft. I feel that this is as it should be.

10. Now we come to Foraging. Foraging has gone from my favourite past time to my most hated skill. This is why. The new changes FORCE people to group in order to adequately ensure that a source does not run out before materials can be pulled.

This is due to the fact that the stanzas making up an extract brick are so prohibitively expensive on focus & material sources die too quickly if you don't have a careplanner.

The use of careplanning is a MUST at the Q150 mats we were harvesting on the server. Now that is fine except for the fact that:

a. Careplanners get bupkiss in terms of XP compared to the actual person pulling the mats.

b. The -32 focus credit is gone with no intermediates in between -24 and -64. This in combination with the increased costs of stanzas that make up the brick make a forage pull extremely expensive on one's focus pool. In a team of two using adequate level appropriate speed, rates, quality & careplans the both of us completely drained our focus pool of 1500+ on ONE pull that took in all of 5 mats of Q140. This barely gave me 300 XP and the puller 1100 XP. This is absolutely unacceptable in terms of meeting material needs for crafters & meeting an XP rate for decent character progression especially for the careplanner.

I realise that there was concern that foragers were levelling too quickly but this is the entire opposite end of the spectrum here folks. Those of you who have high forage and access to the ATS server should check it out immediately. If we get on the Devs case there is still time to salvage the situation. After all if anything, foragers spend a lot of time levelling as it is and melee/magic level much faster, rapidly outstripping the abilities of our guild crafters to meet level appropriate gear for the guild.

THERE IS STILL TIME TO REMEDY THE SITUATION NEVRAX, I HOPE YOU REALISE THAT YOU HAVE SWUNG FROM ONE EXTREME TO THE OTHER. There is something wrong when you have a profession devoted to providing mats (Foragers) not be able to provide them in an abundance greater than what a hunting party would bring in.

Also foraging is enjoyable as a solo hobby. Please allow those of us who enjoy this aspect of the game (and there are many) to continue. It makes no sense to drag an ability down when it could be enhanced. That is, why nerf things for people who like to harvest instead of giving bonuses for grouping such as group material increases, stability increases while harvesting in groups etc.


With warmest regards,

Cieran
High Officer of the Minyatur

The strength of many, forged into one
Please visit our website's recruit forums or contact me in game if interested in joining.
jadeon
Posts: 24
Joined: Thu Sep 23, 2004 6:40 pm

Re: Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by jadeon »

Well even though I was a beta tester, as well as a pre-ordering customer, I have no access to the test servers, my elder of atys title, or my pre-order "gift". So I cannot access these servers to test. However what I can say is judging by this post as well as many of the horror stories of the changes I've read elsewhere, if these changes go through, and this is not a threat, I will be leaving this game. Many of my guild members have voiced the same opinion on the matter. The fact that ryzom relies on a player based economy is awesome. I am an armor crafter and can barely meet the demand of my customers as it is with the speed at which armor degrades. When the patch goes through, pulling materials at this slow of a rate would make it nigh impossible to keep up with crafting, and will ultimatly discourage many players who are potentially interested in breaking into this area. So what does that leave them in the game. Endless monster hunting? Like I said, this reply is not to be taken as a threat but hopefully as some sort of advice. Please re-think this patch. I understand the fact that harvesting was to easy and I agree. The ability to change modes needed to be fixed, as well as taking no damage from gas. The explosions worked fine, but forcing players to depend on others for the skill to work with any sort of effectiveness is ridiculous. I would comment on some of the other problems associated with changes to harvesting, but until I can varify them as fact I would prefer not to.

Noxian
Leader of Heaven's Flame
User avatar
stellus
Posts: 356
Joined: Thu Sep 23, 2004 8:38 pm

Re: Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by stellus »

All I can say is that those Amps look awesome. What a great art team they have.
kisedd
Posts: 221
Joined: Thu Sep 23, 2004 9:58 pm

Re: Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by kisedd »

Other than some not so fun changes to harvest mentioned. I wanted to mention that I think they went overboard on damge for the 50-100 range. I can't speak to higher level mobs. Dying in 3 hits to some scary gingo or vigilant kipee at level 60 just isn't fun.
echofive
Posts: 5
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2004 6:36 pm

Re: Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by echofive »

I totally agree, if the description posted here of the new foraging chages is ANYWHERE near accurate (and I believe it is) then it's one of those deal breakers that will get people to stop playing this game. (myself possibly included, I love the harvesting / crafting aspect of this game, but I mean it is already much slower than fight / magic, I don't understand the need to slow it down MORE). I love the game, don't get me wrong, but lets face it, this sounds like a gimp of a reasonably well working system, and a gimp to the point of almost destroying an entire profession, mabye two. I mean what am I supposed to level my craft skills off of if not off the mats I harvest to raise my forage. I don't know , but PLEASE PLEASE dev's pay attention to this thread, I REALLY do not want to see this happen to my forage skills (forage is not overpowered at all, it is actually extremely tedious and takes a LARGE devotion of time, I spent 6 hours online today just to forage enough mats to go from 45-49 in range weapon crafting) Anyway, heres hoping they don't ruin one of my favroite aspects of the game.
User avatar
tleilaxu
Posts: 163
Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2004 8:56 pm

Re: Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by tleilaxu »

echofive wrote:I totally agree, if the description posted here of the new foraging chages is ANYWHERE near accurate (and I believe it is) then it's one of those deal breakers that will get people to stop playing this game. (myself possibly included, I love the harvesting / crafting aspect of this game, but I mean it is already much slower than fight / magic, I don't understand the need to slow it down MORE). I love the game, don't get me wrong, but lets face it, this sounds like a gimp of a reasonably well working system, and a gimp to the point of almost destroying an entire profession, mabye two. I mean what am I supposed to level my craft skills off of if not off the mats I harvest to raise my forage. I don't know , but PLEASE PLEASE dev's pay attention to this thread, I REALLY do not want to see this happen to my forage skills (forage is not overpowered at all, it is actually extremely tedious and takes a LARGE devotion of time, I spent 6 hours online today just to forage enough mats to go from 45-49 in range weapon crafting) Anyway, heres hoping they don't ruin one of my favroite aspects of the game.
Oh it is accurate all right.

Independent confirmation has been posted on another guild's website.
http://www.ryzom.twazz.net.

Cieran
High Officer of the Minyatur

The strength of many, forged into one
Please visit our website's recruit forums or contact me in game if interested in joining.
ctusk
Posts: 98
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 5:38 am

Re: Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by ctusk »

These changes are pretty much a death sentence to the game.
User avatar
shrike
Posts: 556
Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2004 2:26 am

Re: Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by shrike »

tleilaxu wrote:...In a team of two using adequate level appropriate speed, rates, quality & careplans the both of us completely drained our focus pool of 1500+ on ONE pull that took in all of 5 mats of Q140....
Er... I really cannot confirm this. Getting 5 ~q140 mats takes me alone about 1000 focus, using a -125 prospection and -102 extraction credit and agressive rate 5 and speed 2. Have a focus pool of 2075 and a reg rate of 75.

This is for two-three extraction totally. Being alone I can rearely get 5 from one source, since it dies on me earlier, but 3 take me exactly 669 focus, including the prospection. With someone healing the source I strongly doubt I need more than 800-900 focus for 5 from one extraction, since the mat extraction rate grows a lot faster from 4-5 than 1-3.

edit: screenie for any doubters
http://img80.exs.cx/img80/4208/screenshot28.jpg
Last edited by shrike on Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:43 am, edited 1 time in total.
RUN

[size=-1]Silverion, while being last person alive in the party[/size]
User avatar
botello
Posts: 114
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 8:57 pm

Re: Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by botello »

Nevrax, I hate you with every fiber in my body...
ctusk
Posts: 98
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 5:38 am

Re: Impressions of Chapter 1 from ATS: of special interest to those who forage.

Post by ctusk »

shrike wrote:Er... I really cannot confirm this. Getting 5 ~q140 mats takes me alone about 1000 focus, using a -125 prospection and -102 extraction credit and agressive rate 5 and speed 2. Have a focus pool of 2075 and a reg rate of 75.

This is for two extraction totally. Being alone I can rearely get 5 from one source, since it dies on me earlier, but 3 take me exactly 600 focus, including the prospection. With someone healing the source I strongly doubt I need more than 800-900 focus for 5 from one extraction, since the mat extraction rate grows a lot faster from 4-5 than 1-3.
Great, now take that and grab me 3000 mats that stack so I can level 5 levels in craft. Oh, q170 please.
Locked

Return to “General”