what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Come in, pull up a chair, let's discuss all things Ryzom-related.
Post Reply
3421514
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2006 11:59 pm

what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by 3421514 »

this was a very heated discusion indeed, but why completely remove all traces of it from the forums? This is really a hot topic among the community, and unless you guys are going to do something abvout the mechanics of it all and change how these battles are fought, how can you censor a heated argument that seems to be rallying the players into rethinking their motives for certain actions?

making words disappear in a forum doesn't make deep underlying problems go away..these are discussions we need to have, no matter how heated..censor bad words, but don't censor entire topics...and if you are going to..at least you owe an explanation why

Brock
User avatar
soulsnatcher
Posts: 406
Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2004 10:00 am

Re: what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by soulsnatcher »

It will continue to be discussed, in an intelligent mature way. Flames and abuse will not continue.

Souls
User avatar
kostika
Posts: 1260
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 6:48 pm

Re: what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by kostika »

And actually I asked that the Upping Sticks thread be locked. That is was removed instead is fine with me as it was turned into a horrible thing.
~Kostika
Guild Leader of The Samsara
Atys Guardian

Stand and Deliver!!
naratuul
Posts: 232
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2006 2:42 am

Re: what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by naratuul »

3421514 wrote:this was a very heated discusion indeed, but why completely remove all traces of it from the forums? This is really a hot topic among the community, and unless you guys are going to do something abvout the mechanics of it all and change how these battles are fought, how can you censor a heated argument that seems to be rallying the players into rethinking their motives for certain actions?

making words disappear in a forum doesn't make deep underlying problems go away..these are discussions we need to have, no matter how heated..censor bad words, but don't censor entire topics...and if you are going to..at least you owe an explanation why

Brock
I find myself agreeing with you Brock. Perhaps the more prudent method would be for the mods to delete posts that are deemed over the line, then issue warnings followed by the banstick.

That way a real discourse can be held, and the devs can see the feelings on the street and adjust mechanics appropriately.
User avatar
katriell
Posts: 2479
Joined: Mon May 16, 2005 1:36 am

Re: what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by katriell »

Please don't turn this into an outcry against "censorship." This forum has been NASTY, and it really deserves to be cleaned up.
Jelathnia, Kasarinia, KianShi, Maethro, ShuaLi, and OPaxie (Arispotle)
TeiJeng (Leanon)

ï = ALT+0239 | advice for mission design | Zoraï masks
long-distance communication | some foods and drinks | Zoraï pictograms
"Ryzom: We dare to be different. Do you dare to adapt?" - Acridiel
User avatar
kostika
Posts: 1260
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 6:48 pm

Re: what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by kostika »

Deleting individual comments would leave gaps in the conversation.
~Kostika
Guild Leader of The Samsara
Atys Guardian

Stand and Deliver!!
User avatar
soulsnatcher
Posts: 406
Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2004 10:00 am

Re: what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by soulsnatcher »

As would deleting individuals - so let's just keep it grown up.
3421514
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2006 11:59 pm

Re: what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by 3421514 »

soulsnatcher wrote:As would deleting individuals - so let's just keep it grown up.
agreed..this is something though that is tearing the game apart, and something really need done to moderate it both here and IG, before it blows up to anything worse.

I know I was at the heart of this entire conflict with my little karavan haters move, but all i did was speed up would have happened anyway eventually. It's just good to see that it did get everyones attention and is starting to provide all the input towards solutions

Brock
User avatar
danlufan
Posts: 274
Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 3:47 pm

Re: what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by danlufan »

3421514 wrote:agreed..this is something though that is tearing the game apart, and something really need done to moderate it both here and IG, before it blows up to anything worse.

I know I was at the heart of this entire conflict with my little karavan haters move, but all i did was speed up would have happened anyway eventually. It's just good to see that it did get everyones attention and is starting to provide all the input towards solutions

Brock
How is tearing the game apart? Its making people get into it more...if you own an OP then it can be attacked, hence forth the declare from OmegaV. This is part of the game and you can only see by the mount of people that turns up to them that it isnt tearing the game apart.
~Soloreaper~
~Flame of Atys Guild Leader~
Descendant of Emperor Dexton
rundll32
Posts: 892
Joined: Thu Dec 23, 2004 3:33 pm

Re: what happened to all the posts about Samsara's OP?

Post by rundll32 »

whats wrong with declaring on samsaras outpost exactly....can anyone give me a reason why its wrong....i thought outposts were there to be fought over.
Rundll
High Officer of Order of the Nameless
Post Reply

Return to “General”