Ryzom

whiterider wrote:jared - a guild and its forums are separate. Yes, asking people to join your guild's forum on another guild's forum is no issue, because you can be part of as many forums as you like. The issue is with asking people to join the actual guild, on another guild's forums.

Yes, we are in agreement. But as originally posted, this didn't appear clear so I made an attempt to clarify.

scarazi wrote:I was thinking of poaching Ani actually, not sure if her guild would let me though

think we've all tried at some point

iphdrunk wrote:Uhm... by the way, are you all happy with your current guilds?

Jupp. I still feel happy in my little guild.

Guild poaching is not always bad. In many cases you get your ranks cleaned of less the loyal members and you often get rid of people not contributing anything to guilds that way. Speaking from experience.

But in general, it's annoying and frawned upon, no matter your excuse to do it.


Sweetmarie,

Trying to blame Zella or anyone else for what happened will do you no good. If you want to blame anyone other than yourself blame me. Heck, even accuse me of having a personal vendetta against you if you like, anything goes. Dragging Zella (or any other of my members for that matter) into what was my decission, just because she was assigned a task as a HO, is a no go.

How you will run your guild from here is entirely up to you. Guild recruitment and diplomatic matters alike. You have my full support in creating your guild and all and any ex-ghosts shall be treated with respect. From us and hopefully everyone else. All friendly requests will be welcomed. What you should not do in the long run is thriwing off other guilds because it would only make you look so much worse than what you are trying to make us look like.

Regards

Oh trust me Beren I do blame you.

Your story is that you made the decision, then “executed my kicking” by promoting Zella temporarily to GL and having her do it for you. While this was going on you clearly lied to me by pretending you did not even know it was happening. Now you expect this ridiculous cover-up story to be believed? Nobody that knows you believes you are so spineless to have someone do your job for you. Fact of the matter is that you have been very dishonest.

Now Zella comes to have her grudge with me in a public forum, followed by you accusing your X-members of being less loyal and “not contributing”. Then you say in the same post “any ex-ghosts shall be treated with respect”. You and I had some great times because you are a nice guy, but you are a pathetic leader.

I think this thread should be closed before more mud is thrown. The public forums are not a laundromat.

Agreed and proposed that in my first post.

kalindra wrote:I think this thread should be closed before more mud is thrown. The public forums are not a laundromat.

booooo first bit of drama in months and you propose to close

Thread locked