Ryzom

blaah wrote: *my vote goes to: delete all posts starting from #2 in this thread*

*cough* hmm well can you leave at least my post about what a great guild TPM is tho

This kind of post fits the subject of the thread pretty well dont you think?

l0ol Kara are you meanwhile so desperate to defend a guild like TPM ?
anyway i don't wanna refer to this Kami vs Karavan thing.

My point is that TPM has no right to claim following :

xt1t4nx wrote: and a initiate a foundation for a world where all Homins can soundly flourish in peace and harmony.

and at same time to giving home to ugly things.

That is quite offending to all the other people who state same rightly.

pavmelas wrote:l0ol Kara are you meanwhile so desperate to defend a guild like TPM ?
anyway i don't wanna refer to this Kami vs Karavan thing.

My point is that TPM has no right to claim following :

and at same time to giving home to ugly things.

That is quite offending to all the other people who state same rightly.

your giving it pretty ugly now, that make your guild the same?

And as far as I'm concerned, "pavmelas" and the Kamists have been way more desperate to slander this guild than any Karavaneer has been to defend it. Very shameful of them, really.

From what I've seen myself, The Pyr Militia is a fun and lively guild. What more could a homin ask for?

Wonders if this is the reason the devs are not talking to us about the future thoughts of where ryzom is going?
I am kami and I have no problem with TPM in game as they chose their path of where they wanted to be..
If this makes them happiest in game then why not let them enjoy it.
Please can we all just get along? *mumbles*
Everyone makes mistakes ! Learn to forgive !
Life is like a box of chocolates My mama always told me if you dont have anything nice to say forest, dont say anything at all!

dakhound wrote:your giving it pretty ugly now, that make your guild the same?

I am afraid , you have no sense for comparing ugly things.

If you ever find me login in into a fake account messing with someones else family, you free to compare me.

pavmelas wrote:I am afraid , you have no sense for comparing ugly things.

If you ever find me login in into a fake account messing with someones else family, you free to compare me.

yeah saw it, heard about it, thought it was pretty immature, didnt think it was a capital crime, had worse personal abuse myself, didnt care

was at a time when target was under stress, so effect was amplified, kami did it to doubletap a few times, etc etc,

no reason to be an ass in their guild thread about it, as boroshi said "no trial by forum", offender has been punished and thats all there is to it

dakhound wrote:offender has been punished and thats all there is to it

yep, obviously not by his guild.

Could GMs please clean this thread now?
It's gotten over the top with trolling methinks.

especially from little "won't post my name on forums just in case" people...

Your attitude Pavmelas would really put a stain on YOUR guild so you are wise to keep it hidden. I thought it was cowardice, but I was wrong it's in fact Wisdom!

Keep it up.

komissar wrote:*cough* hmm well can you leave at least my post about what a great guild TPM is tho

Either it's discussion-free guild announcement only, or it includes discussion for all, which means both pro and contra.
I prefer the latter, as it gives an opportunity for both sides of the medal to show. I would rather make an informed choice than one based on propaganda.
If a guild can't counter negative criticism with constructive information (and no, trolling and flaming is not criticism, it's there to be ignored), I'd rather know before I join. If a guild can't cope with constructive criticism, the much the worse.

If only praising were allowed, that'd be even worse censorship than disallowing any comments at all. IMHO even flames and trollish posts should not be deleted, if only for the sake of showing the immaturity of the poster.