Page 3 of 5

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 12:40 pm
by grimjim
philu wrote:And have you entered all 1s? That's what Noin is accusing people of. I want to see some evidence of this.

I've seen fanboy posts encouraging people to vote all 10s (which is probably why it was so high before), where's the evidence people are doing anything but vote honestly (which may be why it's dropped in the ranking).
No, I adjusted down various scores reflecting the event. Community etc.

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 12:42 pm
by philu
grimjim wrote:No, I adjusted down various scores reflecting the event. Community etc.
Exactly my point.

I've just checked the score and it's 8.0 - same as it was last time I checked. I don't think it's EP2 feedback that's dropped it off the page. More like another game has climbed up the list.

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 1:49 pm
by marct
philu wrote:Do you know for a fact that anyone has changed their scores because of EP2?
Some changed their mmorpg review comment to say "I changed to all 1's to express my anger with the PvP" (Or at least that is the basic concept.)

So YES, I do know for a fact.

Noin

P.S. Actually, I was not berrating anyone, but encouraging ALL to score fairly. and not crazy one way or the other. Why do you take everyhting as an attack?
from an mmorpg.com review of Ryzom wrote: On Oct 24, 2005 mague wrote:
Reduced my 9.3 rating down to minimum possible. One of the deepest games with one of the greatest potential ever turned out to become a commerial ganker game. If you like extreme fast leveling to start ganking as soon as possible this is now your game. The old community who kept this game up is not needed any more. So, dont worry they wont disturb any brainless PvP fun.
There were others also, but it does seem they have changed their reviews already, or at least their comments.

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 2:04 pm
by xenofur
in fact, other games did climb up, when ryzom was at position 4 the lowest game had a score of 7.8. it's not that it moved down due to bad scores, it was pushed down by other games with even better scores.

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 2:25 pm
by thosholm
xenofur wrote:in fact, other games did climb up, when ryzom was at position 4 the lowest game had a score of 7.8. it's not that it moved down due to bad scores, it was pushed down by other games with even better scores.
Rather, inflated scores.

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 2:38 pm
by kaetemi
morzyr wrote:Many invested over a year for building the char in their fasion and waited for outposts and some of the features what was suposely be in the game .
Then suddely the game take a turn what they was not ready or had not expected, for as the lack of proper information.
First they're complaining that there's no content, now that there is they're complaining they don't like the content...
And really, they have been giving information on this for months already, and I've been playing for more than a year too...

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 2:44 pm
by grimjim
kaetemi wrote:First they're complaining that there's no content, now that there is they're complaining they don't like the content...
And really, they have been giving information on this for months already, and I've been playing for more than a year too...
The 'content' is hidden behind and linked entirely to 'cheap' PvP.
We won't really know if we like the 'content' until we get to it.
So its not the 'content' itself, but how its presented and accesable that's the problem.

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 2:49 pm
by thosholm
kaetemi wrote:First they're complaining that there's no content, now that there is they're complaining they don't like the content...
And really, they have been giving information on this for months already, and I've been playing for more than a year too...

Kaetemi, stoking the flames is not helping.

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 2:53 pm
by kaetemi
thosholm wrote:Kaetemi, stoking the flames is not helping.
What a weird thing to say to a fyros...

Re: mmorpg.com

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2005 2:59 pm
by gwythion
kaetemi wrote:First they're complaining that there's no content, now that there is they're complaining they don't like the content...
And really, they have been giving information on this for months already, and I've been playing for more than a year too...
It is rather difficult to complain about content before it exists.

Yes information has been out but like many things that information has changed with time and has not always been clear and is open to varied interpretation.