Page 3 of 6
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 1:02 pm
by alyssah
sprite wrote:That's news to me
Ehhmm!! Spriteh you're gonna kill me. In the list you compiled, there is a guild you know very well listed as neutral. I believe that means neither Kami or Kara.
Sorry.
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 1:03 pm
by sprite
alyssah wrote:there is a guild you know very well listed as neutral. I believe that means neither Kami or Kara.
And this will cause problems how?
Edit: just to be completely clear I'm referring to
alyssah wrote: So it certainly won't work later.
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 1:11 pm
by alyssah
sprite wrote:And this will cause problems how?
Spriteh, you were always our expert on fame matters. Perhaps you would elaborate on a neutral stance taken in FvF times. ie. 'later'.
Please note, my main comment was whether or not alliances (immaterial of fame) would be able to combine for Outpost purposes? If not then the little guilds will need to strengthen or wither. I did not think that an alliance could collectively take an outpost.
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 1:12 pm
by hugedan
just kill anyone whos not in the alliance or on friendly terms and not kami based> easy
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 1:21 pm
by sprite
alyssah wrote:Spriteh, you were always our expert on fame matters. Perhaps you would elaborate on a neutral stance taken in FvF times. ie. 'later'.
I'd be happy to
Look
here and note where it says:
"
Guilds would then be able to declare themselves as neutral or from a major faction." So "neutral" will be a possibility
"
A pro-Kami guild would not be allowed to have pro-Karavan members, but neutral members would be allowed." We can only assume this will work for alliances too
"
A non-neutral player with his PvP flag off would be able to join Faction-oriented PvP only by entering a dedicated area." and "Neutral players would not be affected by Faction oriented PvP, whether their PvP flag is on or off." Showing the difference between the two
As for your "main comment", I'm afraid only someone from Nevrax could answer that
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 1:26 pm
by alyssah
Thanks Spriteh. I knew you were the expert.
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 1:33 pm
by catfud
Im confused at this point though, considering that being Kami alligned was the most emphasised point when we founded the GA, when did this change? where was this announced? Was it taken to the vote and if not why?
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 1:55 pm
by keoni
alyssah wrote:Keoni, having been ingame for about 18 months I don't really appreciate you lecturing me about choices of Guilds.
I was making a general reply to the topic of the post, giving my advice to whoever is out there in a situation similar to what I describe. When I say "your guild" I am therefore not specifically referring to MCO or AoA, and I'm certainly not "lecturing" anyone.
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 3:25 pm
by philu
sprite wrote:I'd be happy to
Look
here and note where it says:
"
Guilds would then be able to declare themselves as neutral or from a major faction." So "neutral" will be a possibility
"
A pro-Kami guild would not be allowed to have pro-Karavan members, but neutral members would be allowed." We can only assume this will work for alliances too
"
A non-neutral player with his PvP flag off would be able to join Faction-oriented PvP only by entering a dedicated area." and "Neutral players would not be affected by Faction oriented PvP, whether their PvP flag is on or off." Showing the difference between the two
As for your "main comment", I'm afraid only someone from Nevrax could answer that
Yeah but what about a "neutral" guild where most of it's members have pro-Karavan fame? Eh? What about them? Will they still be able to claim neutrality?
And yes I AM talking about your guild.
Re: Should Guilds be amalgamating now?
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2005 3:29 pm
by hugedan
kept that one quite a sprite