GF - Ryzom Poll

Come in, pull up a chair, let's discuss all things Ryzom-related.

Whats up with the situation?

I see hope for GF and Ryzom.
13
22%
I think GF gave up.
25
42%
I can't tell yet, give me more time.
22
37%
 
Total votes: 60

User avatar
ffxjosh
Posts: 933
Joined: Thu Apr 21, 2005 5:58 pm

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by ffxjosh »

iphdrunk wrote:Anatti / Tylin,

please consider my post not as an agressive one, just another point of view. Apologies in advance if this may sound harsh.

Lol, it's ok, i've 5 brothers, i think i can handle most of the whats said here :p

as much as I am sure that the devs that have prolly being involved with implementing game subsystems, web pages, billing systems etc. since 2000 are passionate and care about Ryzom, I am not so sure about the upper layers of management that bough a game at a bargain, and whose (reasonable) goal is to make a profit are. Their lack of communication and their lack of official commitment from the upper layers of Gameforge, plus the policies of no communications in forums from community representatives (they *are* here, Marjo edited several posts yesterday, just not replying). I am not buying the "Gameforge is passionate about the game" argument at all.

What i dont understand, is that, *IF* GF didnt care/weren't passionate or had no further interest in the game then why would the continue to drain the money from the overall company. If they are losing so much money and they dont want to improve the game (get more subs) then why not cut their losses and run. It's coming up to a year since they took over, i highly doubt that they are where they wanted to be in the grand scheme of things. But they are still here, at least, for now.
I tend to think that a dev that "is likely to leave" has waaaaay more substantial and important reasons to leave, reasons such as being underpaid or not paid at all, unstable employment, status of the company, lack of commitment from or feeling about management not appreciating their work, newer or better opportunities, being tired, and the global feeling as an "insider" and better knowledge of the status of than 30 people ***** in the forums. Give each thing it's weight, the "you are making devs quit"... not sure

Well they stuck through it when Nevrax when bankrupt. The situation they are in now, i would imagine is A LOT better than, say at the end of 2006. Having said that the state of the community and the support the company that runs Ryzom was A LOT better as well.
I am all for it.... as long as we clearly know who are we talking to (a former nevrax dev, a Gameforge representative, a community manager)... and we can go past the market-speech ("there are several options that we are evaluating") .. all in all... I am not sure what can a dev chat bring... given the past experiences. Promises? Commitment? a false feeling of security? Also, I don't see in what "mass movement and asking for a dev chat" and "uproar about lack of communication" differ, but maybe in the manners.

Certianly in the manner, everyone wants something done, but no ones suggested (as far as i have read) one of the most basic, and IMHO, obvious actions to take. You're hapy to ask questions here, but when was the last time a DEV posted on these forums?
I honestly consider that the community is not "moaning" all the time,
Thats relitive and opinionated. Over the past (nearly) 3 years ive been playing, the 'moaning' is worse than its ever been
and I do think that it needs to be done. You cannot "smile and be happy".
I'm not asking them to, I just wanna see more (postive) proactiveness from the community (as well as GF: Paris) Surly that's not too much to ask?
Also, positive answers and some "action" has been the result of "noise past a given threshold".

Could you link me in on that? As I've not seen it (but i rarely frequent the forums, as you can see from my last couple of posts, why. :p )
Tyilin (formally known as Anatti, who was formally known as Tyilin) - Currently Playing Alt.

The First Homin to win the Shield of Presteige

Created theRyzom mooning and the Naughty Spriteh Videos



User avatar
iphdrunk
Posts: 1574
Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2004 8:20 am

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by iphdrunk »

ffxjosh wrote: What i dont understand, is that, *IF* GF didnt care/weren't passionate or had no further interest in the game then why would the continue to drain the money from the overall company.
Precisely, we don't know that. How do you know it's draining now? what proof do we have of *recent* investment and commitment to Ryzom? and that's part of the reasons some players (including myself) would like to know... and, I admit not in benefit of all, the root of all wild-conspiracy-theories. It all began after several days of "silence" despite Marjo still moderating forum posts (see. e.g Gillest thread). Then, someone in the french forums yells that Gameforge France is in trouble. Someone posts in english threads. Someone states that the origianl source (another french forum) seems to be reliable. Most probably some people from GF France play in our shards (coucou, on se connait?)... and rumours explode. Justified? maybe not.

Maybe Gameforge had the best intentions.. at the beginning. Maybe gameforge just wanted to get nevrax assets and abide by law to keep Nevrax employees for one year and "release them". Maybe Gameforge made a market and cost analysis and concluded, recently that it was not profitable. Maybe GF wants to "start anew", or focus on other projects. Maybe some manager changes his mind. Maybe Ryzom can be profitable *if* there are no 21 ex-nevrax employees and just a couple of engineers are dedicated to keep servers running, with minor fixes. They cut costs with Jolt. Why can't they cut costs with devs now?

Maybe, maybe, maybe. No one can state for sure anythng, but it goes both ways. We have no proof and lack of communication
If they are losing so much money and they dont want to improve the game (get more subs) then why not cut their losses and run. It's coming up to a year since they took over,
First, this is what people start to think and what the recent posts claimed "alaaaarm" (What do I know, anyway?) . Someone more knowledgeable than me in French laws stated that in the liquidation terms GF was not only getting Nevrax assets but they were forced to keep 21 employees (as per Phelan words). So.... suddenly , gameforge grows by 21 employees. What income justifies that manpower? either you make them work on projects that are profitable (and Ryzom clearly isn't),you build a whole business around your new market (where are the announcements, where is the marketing, where are the news, why isn't Ryzom in GF wikipedia or list of games). you "invite them to pursuit better opportunities elsewhere",

i highly doubt that they are where they wanted to be in the grand scheme of things.


Maybe they thought they could market Ryzom, make it profitable, and had the best intentions and concluded that they can't.



Well they stuck through it when Nevrax when bankrupt. The situation they are in now, i would imagine is A LOT better than, say at the end of 2006. Having said that the state of the community and the support the company that runs Ryzom was A LOT better as well.



Certianly in the manner, everyone wants something done, but no ones suggested (as far as i have read) one of the most basic, and IMHO, obvious actions to take. You're hapy to ask questions here, but when was the last time a DEV posted on these forums?


Thats relitive and opinionated. Over the past (nearly) 3 years ive been playing, the 'moaning' is worse than its ever been
I'm not asking them to, I just wanna see more (postive) proactiveness from the community (as well as GF: Paris) Surly that's not too much to ask?
Not at all. But you can't blame the players with current state of things and the smajor silence except the "Ryzom is 3 years old".

Could you link me in on that? As I've not seen it (but i rarely frequent the forums, as you can see from my last couple of posts, why. :p )
One that comes to mind without spending too much time digging all threads was e.g. Komissar revolution (I could have looked for a better example). where in less than 10 days not only CSRs but Marjo replied and clarified. Of course, one may argue that OP ame mechanics are a far more "easy" topic than "Gameforge hidden agendas and conspiracy theories and status of GameForge France - ex Nevax"
http://forums.ryzom.com/forum/showthread.php?t=31020
Anissa - Jena's Lost Tribe -

User avatar
dmarxs
Posts: 46
Joined: Wed Jul 27, 2005 4:13 pm

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by dmarxs »

I'm not sure my view of things fit either option in the poll. I was passing a shop toay and saw something for sale in the window. I thought, that would be cool to have, must buy it! I had no use for it, no real idea what I was going to do with it or even how to use it. That's what it feels like to me with GF and Ryzom, it was a knee-jerk thing.

I'm not expecting much.

------------
Taidi
wakatack69
Posts: 103
Joined: Wed Apr 04, 2007 9:52 pm

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by wakatack69 »

dmarxs wrote:I'm not sure my view of things fit either option in the poll. I was passing a shop toay and saw something for sale in the window. I thought, that would be cool to have, must buy it! I had no use for it, no real idea what I was going to do with it or even how to use it. That's what it feels like to me with GF and Ryzom, it was a knee-jerk thing.

I'm not expecting much.

------------
Taidi

*takes bait again* :P

simply put, i do believe GF had the best intentions ever; but those intentions may not expanded much beyond "best"

As a player who was around (other account) when Nevrax annouced its financial dilema, when the community was raising money to BUY the game rights; time was of the essense...

We all need to understand that due-diligence isnt something that happens over night... and GF could only have checked so much, planned so much.. etc etc..

So.... what the oppertunistics (is that a word?) for them [GF]

Simple... a 3D MMO Engine, with a clientel base....

Sure they would have gone over the financial records with a fine tooth comb, magnigfying glass etc, but financial records (spent 7 years in finance) only show so much.

WHY was Ryzom not making money??


Maybe GF thought they could harness the dream, and release the potential.
But maybe... just maybe.... (we alll remember that Ryzom is Nevrax FIRST large scale production game), the coding was in such an atroushis state, that GF released short of starting from scratch; it has proven to be un-econmical to try and "fix it".

Anyway.. i am rambling again....

The point it.. as Dmarxs says above.... I am 100% in the believe... GF wanted to get Ryzom, so someone else didnt.... but have since released they are not in such a good position to use it....




However.. the key point is..... COMMUNICATION


Seriously... i dont care if Ryzom never gets updated again (of course i want it too), but can you please just let us know.


I am curious where GF gets money from...

Metin2 says "FREE FOREVER"...... Ogame (yup played it) has "optional" paid components....




Well anyway.. i am rambling here....


*goes back to work*
Lilijania
User avatar
caaahl
Posts: 635
Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2004 2:26 am

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by caaahl »

Just to confuse a bit more, check your account. In the german communty a lot of (all?) players got since 28th of september "free abo"...whatever this means for the future of Ryzom.
Caaahlhttp://www.elantar.de
Auf daß die stolzen Matis zu alter Größe emporsteigen werden.
User avatar
alisa112
Posts: 175
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2006 10:24 pm

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by alisa112 »

caaahl wrote:Just to confuse a bit more, check your account. In the german communty a lot of (all?) players got since 28th of september "free abo"...whatever this means for the future of Ryzom.

..... :(
Xyrana Delfinyian - Arispotle
Guild Leader

"This above all: to thine own self be true,
And it must follow, as the night the day,
Thou canst not then be false to any man."
User avatar
iphdrunk
Posts: 1574
Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2004 8:20 am

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by iphdrunk »

caaahl wrote:Just to confuse a bit more, check your account. In the german communty a lot of (all?) players got since 28th of september "free abo"...whatever this means for the future of Ryzom.
XXXXX September 9 2007 - October 8 2007 Recurring subscription - 1 month

XXXXX September 28 2007 - ? Free period


Who knows maybe this just means a change in the business and cost model of ryzom. A free subscription game, revenue from advertisment, best-effort service, no development other than minimum maintenance, game "as is" and servers up while it does not cost money? I hope that, if that's the case, release the Kitin nest "as is" :P

In summary, what the free-ryzom campaign promised, but without acess to the source code and without the community being able to implement the extensions themselves.... :?
Anissa - Jena's Lost Tribe -

User avatar
iceaxe68
Posts: 611
Joined: Wed Jan 10, 2007 8:59 pm

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by iceaxe68 »

iphdrunk wrote:XXXXX September 9 2007 - October 8 2007 Recurring subscription - 1 month

XXXXX September 28 2007 - ? Free period
Gaaah, I just resubbed through December...

*thinks about refunds*

*second thought - keep the money if it helps*
Sasi
[size=-4]The Happy Trykerette[/size]



User avatar
macpete
Posts: 36
Joined: Mon Jul 10, 2006 9:47 am

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by macpete »

There are some troubles with the billing system ... Ryzom is not going to be F2P (source: the CSRs).
--
Pietro Cristofoli

tumblr
--
In game: Aristodemus (Tryker)
--
User avatar
kaetemi
Posts: 1547
Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2004 6:33 pm

Re: GF - Ryzom Poll

Post by kaetemi »

macpete wrote:There are some troubles with the billing system ... Ryzom is not going to be F2P (source: the CSRs).
Or at least, that's what they -think- that might be going on at the moment.
<androbia> well i'm suspecting that billing has made a booboo somewhere so i'd suggest you enjoy a free weekend lol coz i don't expect after monday it will be anymore
- Kaetemi [Kami] [Fyros] [Elder of Atys] [NeL Developer]
Rebuild the Kami faction and save Atys from the Karavan! Join the Kami Alliance! Freedom to the Players!
Post Reply

Return to “General”