Ryzom

sprite wrote:What I meant was why should Zysha give it to a side that she doesn't belong to? It's started as a community op and if it was given to a kamist guild then I think its worth as a community op (ie one for the "opless masses") would be devalued.

If it were a community OP then I don't think it should matter what side runs it. Unless it is a faction community OP.

philu wrote:Speaking as a Kami 'follower', I think a community OP should be run by a neutral guild. Then there should be less 'argumant' along faction lines over who gets what.

A noteworthy idea indeed. Of course... politics as they are... ARE there any truely neutral Guilds?

sprite wrote:It's started as a community op and if it was given to a kamist guild then I think its worth as a community op (ie one for the "opless masses") would be devalued.

Is the same as

philu wrote:Speaking as a Kami 'follower', I think a community OP should be run by a neutral guild. Then there should be less 'argumant' along faction lines over who gets what.

There are truly neutral guilds and quite a few of them:
- Order of the Dragonblades
- Veni Vedi Vici
- Red Ribbon Army
- Insomniacs
- The new hope
- Eleytheria
- Fluffy bunnies

just to name a few...

By truly neutral, I meant without affiliation or alliance with a factionally aligned group.

I'm atill a bit unfamiliar with the affiliations of other Guilds

spoloh wrote:There are truly neutral guilds and quite a few of them:
- Order of the Dragonblades
- Veni Vedi Vici
- Red Ribbon Army
- Insomniacs
- The new hope
- Eleytheria
- Fluffy bunnies

just to name a few...

spoloh wrote:There are truly neutral guilds and quite a few of them:
- Order of the Dragonblades
- Veni Vedi Vici
- Red Ribbon Army
- Insomniacs
- The new hope
- Eleytheria
- Fluffy bunnies

just to name a few...

By Rothimar's definition of "True Neutral" the only ones that can be argued imo are Vx3 and TNH. Maybe RRA (sorry but the rabid trykerness is an even larger alignment than factions so I wouldn't count them as such) and I'd say OotDB too but I think most hardcore kamists and some noted members of Samsara would disagree

Last time I checked TNH wanted to stay out of OPs entirely but that might have changed.

spoloh wrote:There are truly neutral guilds and quite a few of them:
- Order of the Dragonblades
- Veni Vedi Vici
- Red Ribbon Army
- Insomniacs
- The new hope
- Eleytheria
- Fluffy bunnies

just to name a few...

Euhm ... there's just one in that list actually for true neutral, and that's VVV. Faction alligned for Altar access isn't neutral in my book, The new hope is deffinatly Karavan alligned according to Naratuul, and both the Order of the Dragonblades and the Red Ribbon Army could be classed in the 'neither' category rather than neutral.

*Some* guild should challenge that OP...

I would like to see a breakdown of where those cats have been, and are currently being distributed to, and in what proportions....
If im being ignorant and this is posted somewhere else please enlighten me.

Lol what a conclusion! o.O