Ryzom

Sure why not - im in

I see no reason to disallow fighters (ranged or melee or mages) from running around as long as they remain in the arena.

Make them start in melee range if you must, but all should be fair game once the fight starts.

sehracii wrote:I see no reason to disallow fighters (ranged or melee or mages) from running around as long as they remain in the arena.

Make them start in melee range if you must, but all should be fair game once the fight starts.

It would be endless, a lvl 150 rifleman running away for 20mins while the melee cant get a hit, it makes no sence. a launcher or auto launcher can keep 60m between themself and the oposition which is a clear advantage, these are duels not real situations, its a test of if you can do more damage than you receive. Up to tyilin but thats my view and yes its biased as i wouldnt class ranged as my weapon of choice
im not 100% i will be here tyilin i will update soon as i have to move my stuff down to uni on that weekend.

btw whats the rules on using magic enchants during a melee duel?

Why not just add a 4th grouping for ranged. Make it so the people fight naked and the fights won't last too long

Yup - my suggestions:

Add 4th comp for ranged only.

Allow all enchants, self heals, auras etc like in the last event.

Allow all equipment/weapons. Not alot of point in disallowing aen/op weapons unless youre going to check every single entrant for boosted weapons/armour. Doesnt make any sense to me. And that not coming from someone without boosted gear

rundll32 wrote:Yup - my suggestions:

Add 4th comp for ranged only.

Allow all enchants, self heals, auras etc like in the last event.

Allow all equipment/weapons. Not alot of point in disallowing aen/op weapons unless youre going to check every single entrant for boosted weapons/armour. Doesnt make any sense to me.

4th thing for ranged is a gd plan i think keep everyone happy
enchants i dont see the point of as they are dependent on magic skill which in melee/ranged are not the skill being tested
carrying on the rule of no aen/old lands stuf is prolly best to avoid people without complaining, unless there is a set on standby for people without to use

Enchants only for magic event, that makes more sense.

I still disagree on the equipment thing, surely the whole points of getting aen/event items is for pvp events. Seems a waste not to include them, the best pvper is the one who comes with the best skill and the best equipment, thats just how it is. It's not like a first person shooter where 80% of it rests on tactics/skill with 20% on the equipment. I thought i was collecting this equipment for a reason lol. So why would aen/event weapons be disqualified, but boosted items allowed?

rundll32 wrote:Enchants only for magic event, that makes more sense.

I still disagree on the equipment thing, surely the whole points of getting aen/event items is for pvp events. Seems a waste not to include them, the best pvper is the one who comes with the best skill and the best equipment, thats just how it is. It's not like a first person shooter where 80% of it rests on tactics/skill with 20% on the equipment. I thought i was collecting this equipment for a reason lol. So why would aen/event weapons be disqualified, but boosted items allowed?

boosted items are down to luck (genrally as few people have the materials to grind 20 of that item....) where as acess to aen armor is purly down to guild at the moment anyway, if im around i will bring an extra set to loan to people who wish to use it, if we are going down the path of allowing aen

Well, not if you do it in a non guild team. And in the past she was alot easier to kill. And as far as the fvf event items, all you had to do was participate.
I dont know, just seems to me youre disadvantaging the long term players who spent time and effort collecting their pvp gear! I just think disallowing things in general is a bad idea, because its hard to police, and seems a bit silly to limit those who have spent the most time preparing themselves.

rundll32 wrote:Well, not if you do it in a non guild team. And in the past she was alot easier to kill. And as far as the fvf event items, all you had to do was participate.
I dont know, just seems to me youre disadvantaging the long term players who spent time and effort collecting their pvp gear! I just think disallowing things in general is a bad idea, because its hard to police, and seems a bit silly to limit those who have spent the most time preparing themselves.

cant argue with that, personally im not fussed either way up to the big blue boss
as for ranged another event would be gd