As others have stated, it all boils down to the stats of every material you use, not just one. If you have a set of materials that you are using that have little to no rating in an important stat, it will basically ruin the item. Don't just go by the rating of the material (basic, fine, choice, excellent, superb). You have to look closer and keep an eye on the ratings.ente33 wrote:Aha! That would explain it! Thanks guys! No more choice for the leafy bullets of doom!
Also, like Korin said, your skill in that weapon's use (or item for that matter) will directly affect how well you can use it. Only 20 Fighting but trying to use a ql50 weapon? You definitely won't be doing the most damage with that weapon as you could be. Ideally you want to use a weapon as close to your current "level" in that action branch as possible.